Figuring out your Thanksgiving plans is a headache in itself. Hosting Thanksgiving is on a stress level of its own. Figuring out where to get your Thanksgiving pies in NYC this year, well that is where we can step in to help.

Bakeries pop up non stop in New York City and unless you are an extremely loyal customer, who swears there is nothing better than the bakery you buy from, keeping track of the top spots can be a real doozy

Below you will find, what we believe to be, some of the top spots in New York City for buying an incredibly delicious Thanksgiving pie this year.

Our Top 3 Spots for Thanksgiving Pies in NYC (No Particular Order)

1. Little Pie Company
Little Pie Company NYC

Picture your mother or father being the best homemade bakers and that smell you would wake up to or come home to when they would bake pies. Heavenly is the word you’re looking for. Well, that is the Little Pie Company. If you are a first timer at Little Pie Company, and not planning to buy every pie they have, picking out a pie from there for Thanksgiving can be a tough one. If you looked on their site prior to visiting, and knew exactly what pie you wanted, you can completely forget sticking to just buying that pie. Once you arrive and see everything you will stare in amazement and start to fumble your words so be sure to bring a hanky.

My three go to choices.
1. Old Fashioned Apple Pie
2. Pumpkin Pie
3. Mississippi Mud Pie

Location: 424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036

2. Baked NYC
Baked NYC

Grab a bowl and throw in some Picasso, a little DaVinci, the cast from Jurassic Park, and a sprinkle of Nicholas Cage from National Treasure.  Blend on medium for 30 seconds and you should be left with a place called Baked That is the shortest way I could possibly describe Baked and the team at Baked and their owners/founders. I love this place and I’m not sure if it’s because the pies are delicious or how awesome their story/about us page is on their website. Either way, if you have chosen Baked as your Thanksgiving Pie spot, you will not be upset with your choice.

My three go to choices.
1. Classic New York Style Cheesecake
2. Pumpkin Pie
3. Apple Pie

Location: Tribeca – 279 Church Street, NYC, NY 10013 | Red Hook – 359 Van Brunt Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231

3. Magnolia Bakery NYC
Magnolia Bakery

When you think classic, delicious, and friendly bakeries you should think Magnolia Bakery. Magnolia Bakery has the perfect blend of vintage decor making the place feel cozy and welcoming. Since Magnolia opened in 1996, on Bleecker street in Greenwich Village, it has expanded worldwide. Although they went through major expansion they never let that get to their heads. They continue to deliver incredibly tasting sweets, great customer service, and an all around one of kind experience!

My three go to choices.
1. Caramel Apple Pie
2. Pumpkin Praline Pie
3. Apple Crumb

Location: To many to list =)

Some of our other favorite NYC Bakeries
Four & Twenty Blackbirds:
François Payard:
Momofuku Milk Bar:

New Call-to-action

About The Author